10 Signs Your Business Website Needs a Redesign

Your website is the face of your business. It's often the first interaction a potential customer has with your brand, so making a positive impression is crucial. Users form opinions about websites incredibly quickly within seconds, and a poor user experience—whether it's slow loading times, confusing navigation, or a lack of mobile-friendliness—can drive them away. A modern website needs to be more than just an appealing brochure; it's a strategic tool that should be optimised for user experience (UX), mobile devices, and search engines (SEO) to attract and convert customers. Here are 10 key signs it's time for a redesign:

1. Outdated Visual Design – An old, cluttered, or inconsistent design can weaken your brand identity and deter potential customers.
2. Slow Loading Speed – If your website takes too long to load, visitors may leave before engaging with your content, impacting conversions and SEO rankings.
3. Poor Mobile Experience – A website that isn’t mobile-friendly risks alienating a large portion of users who browse on their smartphones or tablets.
4. Low Search Engine Rankings – Outdated SEO practices and poor site structure can prevent your website from ranking well on Google, reducing organic traffic.
5. Difficult Content Management – If updating your site requires technical knowledge or is overly complex, it may be time for a modern, user-friendly Content Management System (CMS).
6. Outdated Technology and Security Issues – Running on outdated platforms can leave your website vulnerable to cyber threats and technical malfunctions.
7. Ineffective Calls-to-Action (CTAs) – Weak or unclear CTAs can result in low engagement and fewer conversions, affecting your business growth.
8. Your Competitors Have a More Modern Website – If rival businesses have a superior online presence, your outdated site could drive potential customers to them instead.
9. Limited Business Functions – A website that lacks essential features, such as e-commerce capabilities, CRM integration, or efficient content updates, can restrict business growth and efficiency.
10. Frequent Website Errors – Recurring technical issues, such as broken links, server errors, or security vulnerabilities, can frustrate users, reduce trust, and hurt overall performance.

Each of these issues can contribute to a decline in engagement, trust, and revenue. A redesign isn't just cosmetic – it improves user experience, boosts search rankings, and supports business growth. Now, let’s explore these signs in detail and discuss how to address them.

10 Major Signs its Time For A Website Redesign

1. Outdated Visual Design

A dated website can make your business seem untrustworthy. Modern users expect clean, visually appealing, and easy-to-navigate websites. If your site looks outdated or inconsistent, visitors may perceive your business as unprofessional.

Signs Your Website’s Design Is Outdated:

How to Fix It:

• Adopt a consistent colour scheme and branding across all pages.
• Ensure your site adapts seamlessly to different screen sizes.
• Use a modern, minimalist layout that enhances user experience.
• Replace outdated visuals with high-quality, engaging images.

2. Slow Loading Speed

In today's fast-paced digital landscape, website speed is absolutely critical for success. Think about it: how long are you willing to wait for a website to load? Users have high expectations, and studies show that a significant portion will abandon a site if it takes longer than 3 seconds to load, especially on mobile devices. Every extra second counts!

Slow load times not only drive users away, increasing your bounce rate, but they also significantly hurt your bottom line. Imagine losing potential customers because your website is too slow. This translates to:

• Reduced Conversions: Fewer sales, sign-ups, and leads.
• Lower Engagement: Visitors are less likely to browse multiple pages, read your content, or interact with your site.
• Damaged Brand Reputation: A slow website can make your business appear unprofessional, unreliable, or even outdated.

And it's not just about user experience. Google also prioritises page speed as a ranking factor. (Refer to Google Search Central Blog: Page experience update). This means that optimising your website for performance is essential for both attracting visitors and improving your search engine visibility. Google's Core Web Vitals, which measure aspects of user experience like loading speed, interactivity, and visual stability, are a key indicator of how well your site performs.

Causes of Slow Load Times

What Can You Do About Website Speed?

If you're concerned about your website's speed, there are several steps you can take:

• Test Your Website Speed: Use tools like Google PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix to analyse your website's performance and identify areas for improvement.
• Optimise Images: Compress images to reduce file size without sacrificing quality.
• Leverage Browser Caching: Enable caching to store static assets like images and CSS files on users' browsers, so they don't have to be re-downloaded on every page visit.
• Minify CSS and JavaScript: Reduce the size of your code files to improve loading times.
• Choose a Good Web Host: A reliable web host can significantly impact your website's performance.
• Consider a Content Delivery Network (CDN): CDNs can distribute your website's content across multiple servers, making it faster for users around the world to access.
• Focus on Mobile Optimisation: Ensure your website is responsive and loads quickly on mobile devices.

Don't let slow load times cost you customers and damage your online presence. By prioritising website speed and optimising for performance, you can create a better user experience, improve your search engine rankings, and ultimately, grow your business.

3. Poor Mobile Experience

With mobile devices accounting for 66.46% of web traffic in Australia as of January 2025 according to StatCounter,¹ it's highly likely that mobile usage in Brisbane is similarly high. A site that isn’t mobile-friendly risks losing a significant portion of its potential customers in this key market.

Signs of a Poor Mobile Experience:

• Text and images appear too small or misaligned.
• Buttons are too small to tap easily.
• Pages load too slowly on mobile networks.

How to Fix It:

• Implement responsive web design techniques.
• Ensure touch-friendly navigation with adequately spaced buttons.
• Optimise page load speeds for mobile connections.

Source:

¹ StatCounter Global Stats: https://gs.statcounter.com/ (Specifically, you can often find the most up-to-date mobile vs. desktop share data on their homepage or within their "Global Stats" section.)

Important Notes:

• Data Fluctuation: These statistics are snapshots in time. Mobile traffic share fluctuates slightly month to month. Always check the source for the very latest data if you need precise figures.
• Regional Differences: Global statistics are useful, but keep in mind that mobile usage varies significantly by region and country. If your target audience is in a specific location, look for data relevant to that area.

sbb-itb-b3bcefe

4. Low Search Engine Rankings

Your website's visibility in search engine results directly impacts your ability to attract new customers. If your website isn’t ranking well, outdated SEO techniques, slow performance, or poor user experience may be to blame. Google’s algorithm prioritises mobile-friendly, fast, and well-structured websites (Google Search Central).

SEO Red Flags

How to Improve SEO

1. Conduct Keyword Research – Use tools like Google Keyword Planner or Ahrefs to identify relevant search terms for your business.
   Note: The Google Keyword Planner isn't directly accessible via a simple link like a regular website. It's a tool within your Google Ads account.
   So, you need to have a Google Ads account (even a free one) to use it. Ahrefs is a paid SEO tool suite.
2. Improve Page Load Speeds – Faster websites rank better and retain more visitors.
3. Ensure Mobile Usability – Implement a responsive design that works across all devices.
4. Use Structured Data – Schema markup helps search engines better understand your content.
5. Optimise Meta Titles & Descriptions – Clear and compelling metadata can increase your click-through rates.
6. Fix Broken Links – Ensure all internal and external links work properly to improve SEO rankings.

A well-optimised website with strong technical SEO and high-quality content will help you rank higher and attract more organic traffic.

Signs your site might be falling behind:

• Your website doesn't show up for key industry terms in search results.
• Search engine traffic has been steadily dropping.
• Competitors consistently outrank you for important keywords.
• Mobile users find it hard to navigate your site.

Modern SEO isn't just about keywords. Your site's technical set-up is just as crucial. For example, using outdated HTTP protocols instead of secure HTTPS can hurt rankings. Similarly, slow-loading sites often see higher bounce rates, which can further impact your visibility.

Common SEO problems include:

• Poor Site Structure – Confusing navigation and poorly organised content make it difficult for search engines to crawl and index your pages efficiently. A clear, logical site structure improves both user experience and SEO.
• Technical Issues – Broken links, outdated coding, and server errors can hinder proper indexing, leading to lower rankings and missed opportunities for organic traffic.
• Mobile Unfriendliness – With Google’s mobile-first indexing, a non-responsive design can significantly impact rankings and user experience. Ensuring your website is mobile-friendly is essential for visibility and engagement.

Tools like Google Search Console can help pinpoint issues like crawl errors or mobile usability problems. Fixing these challenges can help you regain your edge in search rankings.

A well-optimised website focuses on clean navigation, fast-loading pages that work on any device, proper technical SEO, and smart internal linking. These updates can improve your search visibility and attract more qualified visitors to your site.

How to Improve SEO:

• Conduct keyword research to optimise content.
• Improve page load speeds and ensure mobile usability.
• Use structured data to help search engines understand your content.

Google prioritises fast, mobile-friendly, and well-structured websites. If your site isn’t ranking well, outdated SEO techniques or poor user experience may be to blame (Google Search Central).

Generative AI and Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO)

Please also see the additional SEO/GEO section below, which outlines the impact of the rise of generative AI and large language models (LLMs) in search, bringing on the newer concept of Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO). GEO is a strategy that leverages the capabilities of generative AI and LLMs to create content that is search engine friendly and highly engaging for users, thereby improving your site's performance.

5. Difficult Content Management

A website should be easy to update without requiring advanced technical skills. If making minor changes feels cumbersome, your Content Management System (CMS) might be outdated.

Signs You Need a Better CMS:

• Updating content requires help from a developer.
• Publishing blog posts or making changes takes too long.
• Your CMS lacks modern features like drag-and-drop editing.

Solutions:

• Upgrade to a user-friendly CMS like WordPress, Wix, or Webflow.
• Implement a content scheduling system to keep updates consistent.
• Ensure your CMS allows for easy SEO optimisation.

6. Outdated Technology and Security Issues

Web technologies evolve rapidly, and outdated platforms can create security risks. If your website runs on old software, it may be vulnerable to hacking and performance issues (Wordfence).

Security and Technology Warning Signs

How to Fix It

1. Use HTTPS Encryption – Secure your website with SSL/TLS encryption to protect sensitive user data and improve trust.
2. Regularly Update Software – Keep your CMS, plugins, and themes up to date to patch security vulnerabilities and ensure optimal performance.
3. Improve Web Hosting – Invest in a reliable, high-performance hosting provider that includes security features such as firewalls and DDoS protection.
4. Implement Mobile Optimisation – Ensure your website is fully responsive and meets Google's mobile-friendly standards to maintain search rankings and usability.
5. Apply Security Best Practices – Enforce strong password policies, implement two-factor authentication (2FA), and restrict admin access where necessary.
6. Monitor and Audit Security – Regularly scan for malware, vulnerabilities, and outdated software to prevent cyber threats.
7. Replace Unsupported Software – If your website runs on outdated or deprecated software, upgrade to modern solutions that receive regular updates and security patches.

By ensuring your website is built on secure, up-to-date technology, you protect your business and users from cyber threats while maintaining strong search engine rankings and user confidence.

7. Ineffective Calls-to-Action (CTAs)

Calls-to-action (CTAs) serve as guides that direct visitors towards desired actions such as contacting you, making a purchase, or signing up for a newsletter. If your CTAs are weak, unclear, or poorly placed, visitors may not take action, resulting in lower conversions and lost business opportunities (Sage Island).

Signs Your CTAs Are Ineffective:

• Low click-through rates on buttons and links
• Visitors are not completing forms or purchases
• CTA placement is inconsistent or not prominent
• Vague messaging that does not create urgency or interest

How to Improve Your CTAs:

• Make them visually prominent – Use bold colours and high-contrast buttons to draw attention.
• Use action-driven language – Phrases like “Get Started Today” or “Claim Your Free Quote” encourage engagement.
• Place CTAs strategically – Position them above the fold and at key decision-making points.
• A/B test different versions – Experiment with CTA wording, colours, and placements to find what works best.

An effective CTA should be compelling, clear, and placed where users naturally engage.

8. Your Competitors Have a More Modern Website

If your competitors have recently updated their websites with new features, sleek designs, and user-friendly experiences, potential customers may prefer engaging with them over your outdated site. A competitive website gives users confidence in your business and keeps you ahead in your industry (Tiller Digital).

Key Signs That Competitors Have an Edge:

• Their websites load faster and perform smoothly on all devices.
• They feature interactive elements such as chat support, appointment booking, or product customisation tools.
• Their branding is consistent and visually appealing.
• They rank higher in search engines, driving more organic traffic.

How to Stay Competitive:

• Conduct a competitor analysis – Identify what makes their websites more effective.
• Implement new technology – Consider integrating modern features like AI chatbots, video backgrounds, or user-friendly navigation.
• Update your website’s aesthetic – Ensure your website’s design is fresh, visually appealing, and aligned with industry trends.
• Improve your user experience – Streamline the navigation and ensure it works seamlessly across all devices.

By keeping up with competitors, you position your business as a credible and trustworthy option in your industry.

9. Limited Business Functions

Your website's functionality is more than just a behind-the-scenes detail – it directly impacts your business growth. If your site struggles with basic tasks or can't integrate with modern tools, you're likely losing both opportunities and revenue.

Signs Your Website Is Holding You Back

Here are some common issues that signal your website is limiting your business:

• Your e-commerce platform can't handle growth.
• Integrating with essential CRM tools is impossible.
• Content updates require a developer's help.
• Features like contact forms or booking systems don't work properly.
• Payment processing is outdated or limited.

For instance, outdated platforms that lack secure payment gateways or reliable inventory systems can cost you sales. Here's a quick look at how limited functionality impacts key business areas:

What Your Website Should Handle

A modern website needs to handle tasks like:

• Secure payment processing
• Managing customer accounts
• Tracking inventory in real-time
• Collecting and analysing customer data
• Automating marketing efforts

If your site struggles with these, it's a clear sign your platform is outdated and needs a revamp.

Common Technical Issues

Here are some technical limitations you might encounter:

• Slow transaction speeds
• Inability to integrate inventory systems
• Limited reporting and analytics
• Poor mobile experience
• Challenges in updating content

Your website should make running your business easier – not harder. If you're constantly creating workarounds or losing customers because your site can't keep up, it's time to upgrade to a platform that supports your business goals.

10. Frequent Website Errors

Recurring website errors can lead to frustrated users, tarnished reputations, and lost revenue. These issues often signal deeper problems that need immediate attention.

Common Technical Issues:

How to Prevent Frequent Errors:

• Apply security updates regularly
• Monitor form submissions to ensure functionality
• Run routine tests for site features
• Verify backups are up-to-date
• Check site performance and load times

If these errors persist, it may be time for a full redesign.

Recurring website errors can lead to frustrated users, tarnished reputations, and lost revenue. These issues often signal deeper problems that need immediate attention.

Common Technical Issues

Here are some of the most common website errors and their potential impact:

How Errors Affect Performance

Did you know that 40% of users leave a website if it takes longer than three seconds to load? Slow load times and other performance issues not only drive users away but also hurt your bottom line by reducing conversions and revenue.

The Hidden Costs of Technical Problems

Website errors often point to bigger, less obvious problems, such as:

• Outdated plugins that create security risks
• Malfunctioning theme elements that disrupt display or functionality

These hidden issues require more than quick fixes – they demand consistent and thorough maintenance.

Keeping Your Website in Check

To prevent frequent errors, ongoing maintenance is a must. This includes:

• Applying security updates regularly
• Monitoring form submissions to ensure functionality
• Running routine tests for site features
• Verifying backups are up-to-date
• Checking site performance and load times

When to Consider a Full Redesign

Persistent errors might mean your website needs more than just patchwork solutions. Signs that a comprehensive overhaul might be necessary include:

• A high number of user complaints
• Inconsistent server response times
• Frequent form submission failures
• Poor results from security scans
• Problems with mobile compatibility

If these issues keep cropping up, it’s a clear signal that your website’s foundation is no longer meeting the demands of modern users. A full redesign could be the best way forward.

And now the future is here. Additional considerations for website SEO and GEO…

How Traditional SEO Principles Relate to Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) and the Future of Search

How Traditional SEO Still Matters (But Adapts):

• Keyword Research: Still relevant, but the focus shifts. Instead of just targeting individual keywords, GEO needs to understand user intent behind complex, conversational queries. LLMs can understand natural language better, so SEO needs to adapt to how people actually speak and search. Think longer, more specific queries.
• Page Load Speed & Mobile Usability: Absolutely essential. Even with AI-powered search, a fast and mobile-friendly site is crucial for user experience. If the AI is summarising or pulling information from your site, it needs to be able to access and process it quickly.
• Structured Data: Even more important. LLMs rely on structured data to understand the content and context of your website. Accurate and comprehensive schema markup will be vital for helping AI understand your content and present it correctly in generative search results.

What Changes with GEO:

• Content Optimisation: The focus shifts from optimising for keywords to optimising for topics and user needs. Content needs to be comprehensive, authoritative, and helpful to answer complex questions that users might ask generative AI. Think "content clusters" and "pillar pages" that cover a broad topic in depth.
• E-E-A-T: Expertise, Experience, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness become even more critical. AI will likely prioritise content from sources it deems trustworthy and authoritative. Building a strong reputation and demonstrating expertise in your niche will be essential.
• Focus on User Experience: Even more important. Generative AI is designed to provide the best possible answer to a user's query. If your website provides a poor user experience, the AI is less likely to pull information from it.
• Beyond Rankings: Traditional SEO focuses on ranking high in search results. With generative AI, the focus shifts to being the best answer. You want your content to be the one that the AI chooses to present to the user.
• Prompt Engineering: Understanding how users formulate their queries (prompts) will become crucial. SEO professionals will need to understand the nuances of natural language and how to create content that effectively answers the questions users are likely to ask.

The Future of Search:

• Hybrid Approach: It's likely that search will become a hybrid of traditional keyword-based results and AI-generated answers.
• Personalisation: AI will enable even greater personalisation of search results, tailoring responses to individual user preferences and needs.
• Voice Search: Voice search, which is inherently conversational, will likely become more prevalent.
• Multimodal Search: Search might expand beyond text to include images, videos, and other forms of media.

Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) and the Future of Search: Why Your Outdated Website Needs a Redesign

The world of search is evolving rapidly, driven by the rise of generative AI and large language models (LLMs). This evolution introduces a new concept: Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO). While traditional SEO principles remain important, they must adapt to this shift. And for websites that are outdated, this means a redesign is not just a good idea—it's becoming essential.

Here's why:

• Meeting User Intent in a Conversational World: Search is becoming more conversational. Users are asking complex questions, and AI is designed to provide comprehensive answers. Outdated websites, often structured around keywords rather than topics, struggle to meet this new user intent. A redesign allows you to restructure your content to address user needs in a more natural, conversational way.
• Content Optimised for Topics, Not Just Keywords: GEO focuses on optimising for broader topics and user needs, not just individual keywords. Outdated websites, with their often thin and keyword-stuffed content, are ill-equipped for this. A redesign allows you to create comprehensive, authoritative content clusters that cover a topic in depth, making your site a valuable resource for both users and AI.
• E-E-A-T: Expertise, Experience, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness: AI prioritises content from sources it deems trustworthy. Outdated websites often lack the design and content quality signals that build trust. A modern redesign, with a focus on clear branding, professional design, and high-quality content, can significantly improve your E-E-A-T signals.
• Structured Data: The Key to Understanding: LLMs rely on structured data to understand your website's content. Outdated websites often have poor or missing schema markup. A redesign provides the opportunity to implement comprehensive structured data, making it easier for AI to understand and present your content correctly.
• User Experience: Paramount: AI is designed to provide the best possible user experience. Outdated websites, with their clunky navigation, slow loading times, and lack of mobile-friendliness, fail to meet modern user expectations. A redesign is essential to create a seamless, engaging, and mobile-first experience that will please both users and AI.
• Mobile-First Indexing and Beyond: Google's mobile-first indexing has already made mobile-friendliness crucial. The rise of voice search and multimodal search further emphasises the need for a modern, responsive design. An outdated website will struggle to keep up.
• Staying Competitive: As search evolves, websites that don't adapt will be left behind. A redesign is not just about aesthetics; it's about ensuring your website is ready for the future of search and can effectively attract and engage your target audience.

In short, a website redesign is no longer just a cosmetic upgrade; it's a strategic imperative for businesses that want to thrive in the age of generative AI and the evolving search landscape. It's about future-proofing your online presence and ensuring your website remains a valuable asset for years to come.

A Website Redesign: A Strategic Investment in Your Business Future

Is your website outdated, slow, difficult to find in search results, lacking essential features, or plagued by errors? If so, it's not just a matter of aesthetics—it's a critical business issue. An outdated website can actively hinder your growth and prevent you from reaching your full potential. A website redesign is a strategic investment that goes beyond cosmetic updates; it's about building a powerful online presence that supports your business goals and drives tangible results.

In today's rapidly evolving digital landscape, particularly with the rise of AI-powered search and Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO), a modern, high-performing website is more crucial than ever. It's not just about looking good; it's about being found, understood, and chosen by both human visitors and search engines.

When planning a redesign, partnering with experienced professionals who understand both the technical and business aspects of web development is essential. Digital Juice Solutions, serving Brisbane's Bayside and Redlands areas, specialises in crafting custom WordPress websites designed to address these critical challenges and capitalise on the opportunities presented by GEO.

Key Benefits of a Website Redesign

A well-executed website redesign isn’t just a refresh—it’s a transformative step towards long-term business success. Let Digital Juice Solutions help you create a website that works for your business, not against it.

Related Blog Posts

• 10 Essential Features Every Small Business Website Needs in 2025